Should Star Wars cease to me made?

It should end on a much better note.

Difficult question

I for one largely disapprove of the direction Kathleen Kennedy and the Story Group (whoever they are) have taken the franchise in, where it feels like it’s become a means to an end. They don’t seem to get Star Wars at a fundamental level, and some of the LFL employees like Pablo Hidalgo, have this strange contempt and feeling of superiority to the fandom that I think is partly at the root of the problem. Until there’s a major change in the committee, I don’t see much to be hopeful about.

Perhaps the one light has been Dave Filoni, who does *get Star Wars, albeit with an important asterisk that he does differ from Lucas’s interpretation of the story. In the end though, asking for Star Wars to be 100% faithful to everything George Lucas is an impossible task now, because inevitably every new creative will bring something to the table that differs. We really only have now Star Wars according to x. 

There’s a part of me that wishes George had never sold Lucasfilm to Disney, even if it meant the end of the company and no new Star Wars going forward. The other side of the coin is what Camille Paglia said in an interview a couple years ago:

I told a TV interviewer in Toronto several weeks ago that a parallel could be drawn with Homer’s epics about the Trojan War, the Iliad and the Odyssey, which date from around 750 B.C. For centuries afterward, Homer inspired hundreds of imitators churning out second- and third-rate poems about the Troy saga. It wasn’t until Vergil wrote the Aeneid shortly before the birth of Christ that there was another major epic about the Trojan War that reached the same level of brilliance as Homer’s originals. The same thing here—sure, there might be some bland or mediocre Star Wars films for a while, but then some day, a film-maker of genius will come along who is Lucas’ true artistic heir. I suspect that only a corporate enterprise of Disney’s size and scale can ensure that the creative matrix for Star Wars will survive until that pivotal, redeeming moment.

I don't think what I said above disagrees with anything you have said here. It is true that Disney's approach to the making and marketing of The Force Awakens was a clear break with the Prequels, that being said, when Disney decided to designate the EU as non-canon, the Prequels were spared the same fate.  Like I said, that is one good thing Disney has done.